In its response to the Environmental Audit Committee’s (EAC) recent PFAS inquiry, the UK Government has not adopted the Committee’s core recommendations to urgently reduce PFAS emissions, but recognise the importance of closer alignment with EU chemical regulations
Over the past year, the EAC heard from a wealth of PFAS experts, academics, industry, the private sector and NGOs, building the case for urgent, group-based regulation of these “forever chemicals”. Taking this evidence on board, the Committee published 20 recommendations, including strengthening the use of the precautionary principle, bringing forward an urgent restriction of PFAS in non-essential applications, and reforming UK chemical regulations (UK REACH) by March 2027.
Source control must be prioritised
Rather than engaging with these recommendations, the Government’s response repeatedly falls back on its PFAS Plan. Defra published the PFAS plan earlier this year, but it has faced criticism for a lack of measures to restrict PFAS at source. As EAC Chair Toby Perkins MP put it, the PFAS plan is “a plan to consult on whether to have a plan”.
The Government’s response to the EAC inquiry insists the PFAS plan already sets out the appropriate approach to PFAS emissions and embeds the precautionary principle. But for a class of chemicals defined by their extreme persistence, many with proven harms to human and environmental health, the only truly precautionary approach is source control.
Promising closer EU alignment, but lacking urgency
As the EU continues to progress swiftly towards a comprehensive restriction of non-essential PFAS uses, the EAC was clear that the UK should align more closely with the EU to avoid unnecessary regulatory divergence. A key part of this will be reforming UK REACH; the EAC called for accelerated timelines, with reform by March 2027.
In its response, it is promising to see Defra recognise the importance of aligning with the EU’s restrictions. However, the Government’s response stops short of committing to how far it will align, and instead reiterated its existing commitment to reform REACH by December 2028, over two years away.
Defra’s response to the EAC’s inquiry doesn’t reflect the pace the evidence demands. Further delays to source control and EU alignment risk widening this regulatory gap with other countries. In the meantime, PFAS will continue to build up in the UK’s rivers, soils, food and people.
As other nations progress with restrictions and scientists continue to uncover new PFAS hotspots and health concerns, it’s now on the UK Government to show it grasps the scale of the problem, and to start delivering the source control measures needed to match it.
