This week the UK Government have published a plan for tackling the forever chemicals, PFAS. The plan has been much anticipated following it’s announcement in the Government’s revised Environmental Improvement Plan, published late last year. Despite some vivid acknowledgements of the ‘irreversible harm’ PFAS can present, the plan falls short on meaningful action to prevent further PFAS pollution at source.
The PFAS problem
PFAS are a group of over 10,000 engineered chemicals used in a wide number of everyday and industrial products, including food packaging, clothing and pesticides. However, these so called ‘forever chemicals’ are now facing international scrutiny for their harmful health and environmental impacts.
PFAS pollution impacts us all. It’s in our food, our water, in our products used around the house, in dust that gathers behind our sofas, and for the vast majority of us, it’s already in our bodies. They are in our rivers, soils and some of the UK’s most beloved wildlife, such as the otter. Even beyond our borders, PFAS are gathering in the deepest parts of the world’s oceans and in remote regions of the Arctic. They are passed on from mother to children in the womb and through breast feeding. They persist, bioaccumulate and mix with other substances to create harmful chemical cocktails. They present one of the most challenging pollution crises of our generation, which is why urgent and decisive action is paramount.
This is also why the UK’s newly published PFAS plan has fallen short of expectations.
Shutting the stable door after the PFAS has bolted
The Government’s PFAS Plan, published this week, marks a welcomed acknowledgement of the extent of PFAS pollution in the UK and the need for intervention. The plan includes many promising commitments, such as improving our understanding of PFAS through research and monitoring, encouraging uptake of PFAS-free alternatives and considering statutory drinking water standards for PFAS. However, a crucial omission is a lack of any new restrictions on PFAS use.
Instead, the plan focuses on other approaches, such as improved monitoring, emission controls and voluntary action from industries and the public. Whilst important complimentary measures, without adequate source control, these approaches will fall short of addressing the root cause of the issue. Restrictions are essential if we are to prevent further accumulation of PFAS in the environment. This is currently being pursued in the EU through a proposed universal restriction on PFAS covering all 10,000+ substances for non-essential uses. Alignment with EU chemical regulation would therefore allow the UK to maintain high standards on health and environmental protection from PFAS, avoid trade barriers with our closest trading partner and reduce the burden on regulators by avoiding unnecessary duplication of workstreams.
Prevention must be prioritised as the pragmatic response over reactive remediation and improved monitoring of the damage already caused.
Near wins and quick misses
We were pleased to see the plan acknowledge the need to address PFAS as a group using the OECD definition, a long-standing call from many academics and NGOs, as well as the need for full-life cycle assessments of PFAS. There are also important references made to improving chemical transparency and the role this will play in supporting the recyclability of materials. All three principles could ensure significant victories for managing PFAS, and other harmful chemicals, if properly integrated into concrete actions.
The plan also makes reference to what could and should have been some quick wins by restricting PFAS in consumer products where alternatives are readily available. Several EU member states, including France and Denmark, have introduced sector-specific restrictions on PFAS in products such as cosmetics, textiles, and food packaging, acting ahead of the EU’s planned universal restriction in order to begin reducing emissions without delay. This is an approach we have encouraged the UK to follow, however, the plan makes no such commitments.
The plan refers specifically to PFAS use in food packaging and school uniforms, two sectors where Fidra have demonstrated PFAS-free alternatives are already widely available. Both sectors offered prime opportunities for the UK to begin restricting PFAS and supporting safer alternatives, with UK manufacturers, such as Delipac, already producing PFAS-free food packaging materials. It is therefore disappointing to see these restriction opportunities missed and replaced instead with further unnecessary research and ambiguous timelines for future consideration.
Major sources with major opportunities
Pesticides
In 2022, PFAS pesticides were sprayed on over 10.6 millions hectares of arable crops in the UK, contaminating our food, water supplies and the wider environment. However, there was no action outlined in the plan to address PFAS pesticides. PFAS pesticides are associated with the formation of the short-chain PFAS, Trifluoroacetic Acid (TFA), a highly mobile and persistent PFAS currently being reviewed for classification as toxic to reproduction in the EU. In research conducted by Fidra and the University of York last year, TFA was found to be present in 98% of sites tested in rivers across the UK. In response to their connection with TFA, Denmark has recently withdrawn 6 pesticide active ingredients from use, all of which are still approved for use in Great Britain. Addressing TFA and wider PFAS pollution from pesticides is essential and highlights a glaring omission in the UK’s PFAS plan.
Sewage Sludge
Approximately 94% of sludge from water companies is recycled to agricultural land. As well as nutrients, this treated sludge (or biosolids) contains a complex mixture of chemical and microplastic contaminants from numerous sources, including household drains, urban runoff, landfill leachate, and industrial and hospital effluents. Although it is welcome that the PFAS plan recognises biosolids as a major source of environmental PFAS contamination, the plan again misses the importance of strong source control and thus fails to address the root cause of the issue. Focusing on monitoring and wastewater treatment also risks passing the cost of cleaning up PFAS onto consumers rather then implementing the polluter pays principle.
A way forward
The PFAS plan is described as a “stepping stone” towards a longer-term vision. To fulfil its duty to protect citizens, the environment and the economy, the Government must take the next steps with far greater urgency and ambition. PFAS pollution affects us all, and the longer we wait to turn off the tap, the bigger the flood will be. This plan must therefore be followed by decisive, time-bound action that prioritises preventing further PFAS pollution at source.
Read our full analysis of the UK’s PFAS plan.
